Ok so I didn't sit this exam but if I had I probably would have failed!
Yet again I am absolutely astounded by the incompetance shown in the writing of an exam question.
Q1 Sept 2005 - Asks if the 10.6% apr figure is correct. Examiners report says it was correct - reading the question you can probably guess it's correct before you even check it.
One problem though: IT IS NOT CORRECT !
The actual figure is definately 10.5% which I have verified by use of excel s/s:
I = 0.105127849
I(12) / 12 = 0.008364877 Sum = 13500.00
Month X PV
1 477.5 473.54
2 337.5 331.92
3 337.5 329.17
4 337.5 326.44
5 337.5 323.73
6 337.5 321.05
7 337.5 318.38
8 337.5 315.74
9 337.5 313.12
10 337.5 310.53
11 337.5 307.95
12 337.5 305.39
13 337.5 302.86
14 337.5 300.35
15 337.5 297.86
16 337.5 295.39
17 337.5 292.94
18 337.5 290.51
19 337.5 288.10
20 337.5 285.71
21 337.5 283.34
22 337.5 280.99
23 337.5 278.65
24 337.5 276.34
25 337.5 274.05
26 337.5 271.78
27 337.5 269.52
28 337.5 267.29
29 337.5 265.07
30 337.5 262.87
31 337.5 260.69
32 337.5 258.53
33 337.5 256.38
34 337.5 254.26
35 337.5 252.15
36 337.5 250.06
37 337.5 247.98
38 337.5 245.92
39 337.5 243.88
40 337.5 241.86
41 337.5 239.85
42 337.5 237.86
43 337.5 235.89
44 337.5 233.93
45 337.5 231.99
46 337.5 230.07
47 337.5 228.16
48 432.5 289.96
As you can see in order to equate the pv's of the payments to the loan amount you would have needed to charge an apr of 10.5%.
Big deal you may say, it's only 0.1% out. Well I say that it is a big deal! Imagine you are in the exam, you have a very good grasp of compound interest and everytime you do the correct verification (which can be done by an eqn without excel fairly easily) your answer is over £20 out - you may think you were doing something wrong and spend too long trying to work out where you have made a mistake. Only it's not you who's made the mistake, it's the examiner.
So thanks a lot examiner for once again failing to correctly apply one of the most remedial actuarial principles. Thanks a lot
Thanks for writing such a bad question that I have to have an alcoholic drink 2 days before my exam to try and calm down. Please will someone regulate our examiners!!!!
Last edited by a moderator: Sep 3, 2006