Q&A 3.22 (i) applied calculation

Discussion in 'SP9' started by teddybear2012, Jul 31, 2012.

  1. teddybear2012

    teddybear2012 Member

    Has anyone worked on this question? I wonder how you can use Excel's solver to find 2 Gamma parameters. I think the solver only works to find one parameter. Anything that I missed? Thanks.
     
  2. Avi0013

    Avi0013 Member

    Solver can work on as many parameters as you feed it (click-drag), but I would not trust its answers for more than 2 parameters. For n parameters (n >= 3) it tends to fix n-1 and solve for the last one. Use R or MATLAB for those cases, but for a two-parameter gamma, you should be fine.
     
  3. Simon James

    Simon James ActEd Tutor Staff Member

    Hi. As Avi003 points out you can indeed select multiple parameters in Excel's Solver. In the Solver dialogue box in the "By Changing Cells" field, either select a range or select multiple cells separated by commas.
     
  4. teddybear2012

    teddybear2012 Member

    thanks!

    Thanks. I had some difficulty solving for 2-parameters Gamma in the first place, then after putting constraints as positive, it worked.
     
  5. David Wilmot

    David Wilmot ActEd Tutor Staff Member

    Great to see you giving these spreadhseet calculations a go - I'd be interested in hearing if you feel that they are useful in your exam preparation. Ta, David :)
     
  6. SpeakLife!

    SpeakLife! Member

    I didn't work through this question on a computer. Nevertheless, this question nicely illustrates the concepts of nested models, goodness of fit, and various selection criteria.
     

Share This Page