IAI Q31 confusion

Discussion in 'CT7' started by dextar, Oct 4, 2013.

  1. dextar

    dextar Member

    In the aggregate demand framework, consumption function is given by
    C=100+0.8Yd where Yd is the disposable income. Suppose there are no taxes in this economy so Y=Yd.
    Investment level is Rs 50 and government expenditure is Rs 50.
    What is the level of saving in the economy in the equilibrium state?

    I'm not convinced about the solution. I approached it like this
    in equilibrium
    Y=AD
    Y=Cd + W =Cd+J
    => Cd+ S +T+I =Cd+ I +G +X
    Since exports and imports are 0 and taxes are 0
    S=I+G =50+50 =100
    Any problems here? Solution says S=50 what is the problem in this approach?
     
  2. Margaret Wood

    Margaret Wood Member

    This is a strange question in that G=50 and yet T=0. How does the government finance its expenditure???

    However, assuming that G=50, I=50, and that X=M=T=0, your method is fine and I agree with your answer of 100.

    Alternatively, the equilibrium income could be found by setting AggD=Y, where AggD=C+I+G+X-M = 100+0.8Y+50+50 = 200+0.8Y. Setting this equal to Y gives an equilibrium income of 1,000. Since C=100+0.8Y, S=Y-C=Y-(100+0.8Y)= -100+0.2Y, so when Y=1,000, S= 100.
     
  3. dextar

    dextar Member

    Thanks Margaret for attempting this . This is ths part of solution given by them
    Y=C+I+G= Aggregate demand
    Y=100+0.8Y+50+50
    Therefore, Y= (200/0.2)= Rs 1000
    Saving in the economy= Income – Expenditures in the economy
    We know from a) that income is Rs 1000
    Expenditure=Consumption expenditure plus government expenditure
    = 100 + 0.8*1000 + 50
    = 950
    Therefore, Saving= 1000 – 950
    = Rs 50

    However, I don't agree with the line marked with yellow why are we additing another 50?
     
  4. Margaret Wood

    Margaret Wood Member

    I'm not sure what they're saying on the yellow line!

    Total expenditure at equilibrium is C+I+G= 100 +0.8(1000)+50 +50 = 1000.

    Consumer expenditure at equilibrium C = 100 +0.8(1000)=900.

    Savings is defined as that part of disposable income that is not spent, ie S =Yd-C, which in this case, since there are no taxes, = Y-C = -100+0.2Y, so at equilibrium, S=-100+0.2(1000) = 100 or more simply, S= Y-C= 1000-900=100.

    Alternatively, as you did, you can say that at equilibrium, planned injections equal planned withdrawals, ie S+T+M=I+G+X, ie S+0+0 = 50+50+0, so S=100.

    Whichever way you do it, the answer is 100!
     

Share This Page