• We are pleased to announce that the winner of our Feedback Prize Draw for the Winter 2024-25 session and winning £150 of gift vouchers is Zhao Liang Tay. Congratulations to Zhao Liang. If you fancy winning £150 worth of gift vouchers (from a major UK store) for the Summer 2025 exam sitting for just a few minutes of your time throughout the session, please see our website at https://www.acted.co.uk/further-info.html?pat=feedback#feedback-prize for more information on how you can make sure your name is included in the draw at the end of the session.
  • Please be advised that the SP1, SP5 and SP7 X1 deadline is the 14th July and not the 17th June as first stated. Please accept out apologies for any confusion caused.

Degrees of freedom for hand graduation

J

jensen

Member
If you have 9 age groups, and you performed graphical graduation on the rates, how many degrees of freedom do you assume for Chi Square test statistic?

Solution 12.19 says 6 or 7, but I thought it should be 8.
 
The core reading for graphical graduation states: "A rule of thumb sometimes used is that 2 or 3 DF are lost for every 10 or so ages/ age groups fitted, corresponding roughly to the determination of the height, slope and (perhaps) curvature over that section of the curve."

Even if there are 9 age groups, it should be appropriate to reduce 2 or 3 DFs. I faintly recall a solution set stating "reduce 1 DF each for height, slope and curvature". As curve fitting in a graphical graduation will have to deal with height, slope and curvature, I feel one should reduce 1 DF for each of these i.e. 3 in all.
 
Thanks Ankmola

I realised that after I completed chapter 13. Funny that they have not mentioned anything about it before putting up a question such as this in a chapter that does not touch anything on degrees of freedom for hand graduations.
 
Back
Top