Chapter 10 queries

Discussion in 'CT4' started by rinishj28, Jan 14, 2014.

  1. rinishj28

    rinishj28 Member

    1.Why does the poisson model not allow increments?

    2. Chapter 10:page 17-Please explain this part:
    Under the observational plan described above, the poisson model is not an exact model, since it allows a non zero probability of more than N deaths. But it is often a good approximation, since the probability of more than N deaths is usually negligible

    3. Can I say that the reason why the two state model can consider the time at which a transition takes place is cause it uses mu whereas the binomial cannot as it uses a moment estimate to calculate qx?
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 14, 2014
  2. Calum

    Calum Member

    (1) I'm not quite sure what you're asking here, sorry.

    (2) The Poisson model says that the number of deaths is Poisson distributed. A Poisson distribution can in theory be any positive integer. Since you only have N people that can die, obviously it's impossible to actually get more than N deaths. However, if you actually look at P(deaths>N) it's clear the probability is very low.

    (3) The difference is how you estimate the parameters, which comes from the likelihood functions. For binomial, you just need to know in which time interval the life died; for the two state model you need the exact time spent alive so you need the exact time of death.
     
  3. rinishj28

    rinishj28 Member

    Thank you very much.
     
  4. Hemant Rupani

    Hemant Rupani Senior Member

    Poisson model allows independent increments.
     
  5. John Potter

    John Potter ActEd Tutor Staff Member

    I think there might be a bit of confusion here over the original Question (1)

    Regarding the Poisson model of mortality studied in Chapter 10

    While the two state model can be specified so as to allow for increments (ie lives entering the population), this is not possible for the Poisson model.

    Regarding a Poisson process as introduced in the earlier chapters

    A Poisson process has independent increments by definition.

    The independent increments of a Poisson process have nothing to do with the fact that the Poisson model of mortality does not allow for increments,

    Good luck!
    John
     

Share This Page