301, April 2004 Q7

Discussion in 'SP5' started by Gareth, Mar 8, 2007.

  1. Gareth

    Gareth Member

    This comes from ASSET April 2004, Q4.

    The solution works out quarterly performance figures for:

    a) Benchmark allocation and benchmark assets to be:

    Q Return (%)
    1 2.4
    2 -6.695
    3 2.888
    4 3.063

    b) Actual allocation and actual assets to be:

    Q Return (%)
    1 -7.083
    2 -1.544
    3 4.68
    4 31.94

    This gives difference actual - benchmark as:

    Q Return (%)
    1 -9.483
    2 5.16
    3 1.79
    4 28.88

    Now it states "adding together the quarterly out performances gives an overall relative out performances over the year of 26.3%".

    I am suspicious of this, how can you just add up the quarterly returns? Surely it should have been doing (1 + diff1) x (1 + diff2) x ... x (1 + diffn) - 1??? (as this is basically a TWRR)

    This is materially different to the stated answer (would give 24.9%).

    What do you think?
     

Share This Page